Wins

Name

School(s)

Years

549

Chris Messina*

Hauppauge

1982-2024

436

Lou Giani

Huntington (and Eastern Military Academy)

1969-2008

430

Bill Santoro*

Connetquot

1979-2024

373

Bill DeSario

Babylon, Commack, and Ward Melville

1970-1989, 2001-2016

350

Ralph Napolitano*

Brentwood

2003-2024

341

Jack Mahoney

Sachem

1973-2005

315

Paul Bass

Westhampton

1988-2019

312

Tony Mellino

West Islip

1975-2006

309

Joe Patrovich

Islip (and East Meadow, Division, & Plainview JFK)

1978-2014 (26 years)

299

Darren Goldstein*

Rocky Point and Longwood

2000-2002, 2005-2024

285

Joe Condon*

Shoreham-WR

2008-2024

274

TJ Brocking*

John Glenn

2007-2024

270

Guy Leggio

East Islip

1990-2015

263

Norm Maisel

Amityville

1968-1992

261

Gary Pesko*

Sayville

1995-2024

258

Bob Armstrong

Port Jefferson and Westhampton

1969-1970, 1972-1992

252

Joe Campo Sr.

Brentwood (72 additional at Frankfort-Schuyler-III)

1966-1985

241

Walt Stewart

Riverhead

1951-1985

233

Ed Luksik

Deer Park

1964-1973, 1978-1996

232

Matt Armstrong*

Mt. Sinai

2002-2012, 2014-2024

228

Sal DiFazio

Half Hollow Hills

1961-1988

220

Ron Frole*

Lindenhurst

2005-2024

219

Mike Picozzi

Walt Whitman, Longwood

1983-1984, 1985-1994 and 2006-2012

213

Vin Altebrando

Walt Whitman

1995-2018

   212**

Ralph Forman* IV

Commack North, Copiague, Amityville, Harborfields

1978-82, 1984-1987, 1993-2018

212

Robin Winkel

Rocky Point

1979-2004

207

Ray Pickersgill*

Sachem North, Sachem East

2006-2018, 2019-2024

205

Ken Leverich*

Smithtown West

2006-2024

204

Mike Fitzgerald

Hampton Bays

1975-1985, 1987-2001

202

John Szokoli

Harborfields

1971-1997

200

Al Ciccio

Northport

1990-2014

194

Cliff Clark

Bay Shore

1940-1964

190

Matt Kazsubski*

Miller Place

2013-2024

188

Brian Uvena

North Babylon, Walt Whitman, and Roslyn

1982, 1985-1988, 1991-2006, 2010-2014

181

Joe Valla

Amityville

1948-1963

181

Vinny Innes*

West Babylon, North Babylon

2001-2011, 2017-2024

177

Chuck Maragiolio*

Bellport

2003-2024

177

George Buddy Fox

Centereach, Newfield

1971-1982, 1965-1970

177

Mike Maletta*

Port Jefferson

2008-2024

176

Tom Anello*

Patchogue-Medford

2012-2024

174

Cory Dolson

Mattituck

2007-2021

166

Bart Olsen

Hauppauge

1957-1973

164

Fred Duart

West Islip

1957-1961, 1964-1967, 1969-1974

163

Joe Goonan

Half Hollow Hills West

1979-2003

160

Dick Rosener

Bay Shore, Centereach

1980-1999, 2008-2011

153

Brad Brzozinski*

Central Islip

1998-2024

158

Bill Hutchinson

Bayport

197?-1981

157

Jack Stanbro

Lindenhurst (and an additional 188 at Johnson City)

1962-1972

157

Joe Russo

Lindenhurst

1980-2004

151

Nick Garone

Eastport-South

2006-2021

150

Brian Fitzgerald*

Comsewogue

2004-2024

149

Rich Reilly

Bayport-Blue Point

2005-2015

148

KC Beach*

Islip

2016-2024

145

Tony Mecca*

William Floyd

2009-2023

145

Craig Kelsey

Patchogue-Medford

1981-1998

140

Jim Stewart*

East Hampton

1978-2009, 2019-2020

139

Nick Lagiglia Jr.*

West Islip

2009-2024

   138**

Rocky Davey*

Shoreham-Wading River, Mercy, Riverhead, Center Moriches

1983-1989, 1994, 1990-1993 and 1995-2015, 2023

136

David Cummings

Smithtown East

2003-2015

136

Mike Koscinski

Center Moriches, Longwood, Southampton, Mercy

2007-2015 and 2017-2020, 2003-2005, 1997-1999, 1995

135

Rob Jackolski

Bayport-Blue Point

1982-1991

135

Sean O’Hara

Sachem East

2005-2013

130

Terry Phelan

William Floyd

1987-2008

130

Mike Guercio*

Kings Park, Commack

2007, 2012-2024

128

Thadius Alberti

Northport

2015-2024

122

Don Jackson

Smithtown East (1969-1981) and Bellmore JFK

122

Mark Manningo*

Bayport-Blue Point, Stony Brook

1995-2004, 2005-2024

121

Billy Davey III*

Half Hollow Hills East

2011-2024

118

Mike Porcelli

East Islip, Bay Shore

1987-1989, 1995-2004

110

Tony Perna

Newfield

1974-1984

105

Anthony Cipriano

Copiague

2008-2022

104

Rudy Carastro

Babylon

1990-2001

101

Billy Davey

Kings Park

1982-1992

97

Henry Lonnie Kittle

Amityville

1933-1947