Long Island Wrestling Association

 

Donate to Support
the LIWA

Contacts

Association Office
LIWA
117 Dale Dr
Oakdale, NY 11769


Webmaster
Steve Meehan
stevemeehan0809 @ gmail.com

 

Section 11 Results

 Section 8 | Section 11 | CHSAA | Private


Long Island Intersectional Tournament
March 7-8, 1958 at Amityville
Team Scores:
  1. Mepham 101
  2. Amityville 60
  3. Bay Shore 47
  4. Huntington 26
  5. Walt Whitman 21
  6. Lindenhurst 20
  7. Lynbrook 19
  8. Valley Stream Central 16
  9. Great Neck 10
10. Port Jefferson 9
      Massapequa 9
12. Malverne 8
13. Wantagh 5
      Freeport 5
      Valley Stream South 5
16. Kings Park 3
      Uniondale 3
18. Baldwin, Brentwood, Farmingdale, Hicksville, Manhasset, Oceanside, West Islip 0.
Championship Finals
106 - Cliff Furrer (Mepham) dec. Rich Kelly (Mass), 5-3
112 - Mike Randall (Mepham) dec. Charles Hotcaveg (PJ), 6-3
119 - Don Pike (VSC) dec. Jerry Minsk (Mepham), 1-0
126 - John Quigley (Lind) dec. Don Grenier (Hunt), 4-3
131 - Herb Bickel (Mepham) dec. Bruce Daniels (Mepham), 3-1
136 - Ray Connell (Lyn) dec. John Ryan (Mepham), 3-2
141 - Pete Walker (Amity) dec. Anthony Guccione (BS), 3-0
148 - Conrad Zimmerman (Amity) dec. Brian (WW), ?
157 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Tony Brucia (Mepham), 2-01
168 - Ed Hubbard (BS) dec. Cory Henry (GN), 9-4
178 - Charles Schroeder (BS) dec. Kurt Schwarting (Hunt), 5-2
Unl - John Cutillo (Amity) dec. Dave Hayes (Mepham), 2-2 regulation, 1-1 OT, referee’s decision
Consolation Finals
106 - Charles Cirino (Malverne) dec. Jim Willigan (Amity), 6-4
112 - John Bifulco (WW) dec. Justin Aquiviva (VSC), 7-5
119 - Bill Patterson (Lind) dec. Mark Piven (Mepham), 4-3
126 - Ron Weiners (Mepham) pinned Ed Devereaux (Union), 1:1*
131 - John Schultis (Amity) dec. Dave McCoy (Malverne), 2-1
136 - Charles Carmen (Free) dec. Stewart Meyerson (Lind), 5-2
141 - Herb Wolf (Want) dec. Mike Hyland (KP), 5-2
148 - Chris Leftenant (Amity) dec. Jack Karp (Mepham), 7-5
157 - Rich Provenzano (Hunt) dec. Bruno Cerchial (Amity), 2-1
168 - Dan Dunning (VSC) dec, Bob Romanac (Mepham), 4-1
178 - Mike Spetko (Amity) dec. Steve Glynn (Lyn), 3-2
Unl - Cliff Person (WW) pinned John Urguhart (Lyn), 2:52

Semifinals

106 - Rich Kelly (Mass) dec. Jim Willigan (Amity), 9-1
         Cliff Furrer (Mepham) dec. Charles Cirino (Malverne), 8-0
112 - Mike Randall (Mepham) pinned John Bifulco (WW) 1:30
         Charles Hotcaveg (PJ) dec. Justin Aquiviva (VSC), 6-4
119 - Jerry Minsk (Mepham) dec. Bill Patterson (Lind), 1-0
         Don Pike (VSC) dec. Mark Piven (Mepbham), 1-0
126 - Don Grenier (Hunt) pinned Ed Devereaux (Union), 1:07
         John Quigley (Lind) dec. Ron Weiners (Mepham) 2-0
131 - Bruce Daniels (Mepham) dec. John Schultis (Amity), 10-6
         Herb Bickel (Mepham) dec. Dave McCoy (Malverne), 5-0
136 - Ray Connell (Lyn) dec. Charles Carmen (Free), 3-1
         John Ryan (Mepham) dec. Stewart Meyerson (Lind), 6-3
141 - Pete Walker (Amity) dec. Herb Wolf (Want), 2-1
         Anthony Guccione (BS) dec. Mike Hyland (KP), 10-5
148 - Conrad Zimmerman (Amity) dec. Chris Leftenant (Amity), 2-0
         Brian Egan (WW) dec. Jack Karp (Mepham), 6-5
157 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Bruno Cerchial (Amity) 5-1
         Tony Brucia (Mepham) dec. Rich Provenzano (Hunt), 5-1
168 - Ed Hubbard (BS) dec. Bob Romanac (Mepham), 8-1
         Cory Henry (GN) pinned Dan Dunning (VSS), 3:18
178 - Charles Schroeder (BS) dec. Steve Glynn (Lyn), 7-2
         Kurt Schwarting (Hunt) pinned Mike Spetko (Amity), 5:22
Unl - John Cutillo (Amity) pinned John Urguhart (Lyn), 2:52
         Dave Haise (Mepham) dec. Cliff Person (WW), 9-7

Quarterfinals

106 - Jim Willigan (Amity) pinned Joe Genna (Mepham), 4:14
         Cliff Furrer (Mepham) won by default over Rich Droscoski (PJ)
         Rich Kelly (Mass) dec. Chuck Geddes Jr. (BS), 2-0
         Charles Cirino (Malverne) dec. Steve Erber (Hunt), 3-2
112 - Mike Randall (Mepham) dec. pinned Rich Holohan (Hunt), 1:29
         John Bifulco (WW) dec. Weissleden (Ocean), 5-2
         Charles Hotcaveg (PJ) dec. Werner Keller (Want), 4-3
         Justin Aquiviva (VSC) pinned Ed Margioni (Hunt), 3:45
119 - Bill Patterson (Lind) dec. John Plant (Lyn), 5-0
         Jerry Minsk (Mepham) dec. Tony Basile (Brentwood), 10-0
         Don Pike (VSC) dec. Bob Lynch (Hunt), 1-0
         Mark Piven (Mepham) dec. Bryant Notine (WI), 1-0
126 - Don Grenier (Hunt) dec. Cuneo (Want), 2-0
         Ed Devereaux (Union) dec. Bob Donohue (Amity), 2-1
         Ron Weiners (Mepham) pinned Chuck Raio (WW), 1:47
         John Quigley (Lind) dec. Coale (VSC), 5-4
131 - John Schultis (Amity) dec, Bob Emmons (VSC), 4-2
         Bruce Daniels (Mepham) dec. AL Krus (BS), 6-0
         Dave McCoy (Malverne) dec. Doug Helin (Hunt), 7-2
         Herb Bickel (Mepham) dec. DickBraile (KP), 7-2
136 - John Ryan (Mepham) won by default over Jim Maguire (BS)
         Charles Carmen (Free) dec. Tom Coburn (Amity), 4-1
         Ray Connell (Lyn) dec. Steve Erber (Hunt), 5-0
         Stu Meyerson (Lind) dec. LoFrese (Union), 6-3
141 - Pete Walker (Amity) dec. Snee (Baldwin), 8-3
         Herb Wolf (Want) Joe Fusaro (WW), 5-2
         Mike Hyland (KP) dec. Jacobs (Mepham), 12-0
         Anthony Guccione (BS) dec. Gary Sirota (Mepham), 5-2
148 - Conrad Zimmerman (Amity) dec. Dick Duffy (Farm), 3-2
         Chris Leftenant (Amity) Mike Tennant (Mepham), 6-3
         Brian Egan (WW) dec. Don Dunning (VSS), 3-2
         Jack Karp (Mepham) dec. F.P. Sforza (Hunt), 5-1
157 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Black (Manhasset), 5-1
         Bruno Cerchial (Amity) Grieve (Hicks), 6-1
         Tony Brucia (Mepham) dec. Kevin Carty (Amity), 3-1
         Rich Provenzano (Hunt) dec. Argento (VSC), 5-1
168 - Ed Hubbard (BS) dec. pinned Rose (Ocean), 2:40
         Bob Romanac (Meham) dec. Brad Yates (Amity), 4-2
         Cory Henry (GN) dec. Phil Ferdinando (Hunt), 7-6
         Dan Dunning (VSS) dec. Ray Farrell (KP), 3-2
178 - Charles Schroeder (BS) pinned Smith (Want), 5:48
         Steve Glynn (Lyn) dec. Frank Ciccio (WW), 3-2
         Kurt Schwarting (Hunt) dec. McGovern (Mass), 3-0
         Mike Spetko (Amity) dec. Ray Nickla (Mepham), 4-2
Unl - John Cutillo (Amity) dec. pinned Motekew (Baldwin), 5:44
         John Urguhart (Lyn) pinned Dick Areostatico (KP), 2:44
         Dave Hayes (Mepham) pinned Jackson (Free), 3:00
         Cliff Perrson (WW) dec. Tom Ketcham (BS), 4-2

Suffolk Class A Championship at Bay Shore
February 20-21, 1958
Team Scores
1. Amityville 100
2. Bay Shore 78
3. Huntington 59
4. Walt Whitman 51
5. Lindenhurst 29
6. Port Jefferson 18
7. West Islip 9
8. Riverhead 1
Championship Finals
106 – Jim Willigan (Amityville) dec. Rich Drsocoski (Port Jefferson), 9-0
112 – Rich Holohan (Huntington) dec. Chrales Hotcaveg (Port Jefferson), 6-0
119 – Bill Peterson (Lindenhurst) dec. Briant Notine (West Islip), 4-0
126 – Don Grenier (Huntington) dec. John Quigley (Lindenhurst), 9-2
131 – John Schultis (Amityville) dec. Doug Helin (Huntington), 6-2
136 – Jim Maguire (Bay Shore) dec. Stu Meyerson (Lindenhurst), 3-02
141 – Anthony Guccione (Bay Shore) dec. Joe Fusaro (Walt Whitman), 2-0
148 – Brian Egan (Walt Whitman) dec. Conrad Zimmerman (Amityville), 3-1
157 – John Morrison (Bay Shore) dec. Kevin Carty (Amityville), 2-1
168 – Eddie Hubbard (Bay Shore) dec.Brad Yates (Amityville), 1-0
178 – Mike Spetko (Amityville) dec. Charles Schroeder (Bay Shore), 4-3
Hwt. – Cliff Persson (Walt Whitman) dec. John Cutillo (Amityville), 10-8
Most Outstanding Wrestler:
Most Pins Least Time:
Consolation Finals

106 – Steve Erber (Huntington) dec. Chuck Geddes Jr. (Bay Shore), 5-2
112 – John Bifulco (Walt Whitman) dec. Ed Margioni (Huntington), 12-3
119 – Bob Lynch (Huntington) pinned Joe Lombardo (Amityville), 1:20
126 – Chuck Raio (Walt Whitman) dec. Bob Donohue (Amityville), 6-5
131 – Al Krus (Bay Shore) dec. George Hubbard (Bay Shore), 7-6
136 – Tom Coburn (Amityville) pinned Pete Erber (Huntington), 2:57
141 – Pete Walker (Amityville) dec. Pete Flegenheimer (Amityville), 5-1
148 – Curtis Leftenant (Amityville) dec. F. P. Sforza (Huntington), 11-2
157 – Richard Provenzano (Huntington) dec. Bruno Cerchial (Amityville), 5-4
168 – Phil Fernando (Huntington) dec. Skip Schumejda (River), 6-3
178 – Frank Ciccio (Walt Whitman) dec. Kurt Schwartz (Huntington), 4-2
Hwt. – Tom Ketcham (Bay Shore) dec. Len Liebowitz (Walt Whitman), 5-2

Suffolk Class B Championship at Kings Park
February 20-21, 1958
Team Scores
1. Kings Park 130
2. Smithtown 70
3. Brentwood 34
4. Sachem 33
5. Islip 29
6. Northport 20
7. Bellport 19
7. East Islip 19
7. Hauppauge 19
10. Central Islip 1
Championship Finals
106 - Mike Pomara (Sachem) pinned Art Cadieux (Kings Park), 2:55
112 - Bob Selkowitz (Kings Park) dec. Ronnie Hackett (Islip), 5-4
119 - Tony Basile (Brentwood) dec. Bob Scheer (Hauppauge), 4-0
126 - Mike Johnson (Kings Park) dec. Frank Rignola (Bellport), 7-2
131 - Rich Braille (Kings Park) pinned John Vanderlofske (Smithtown), 1:40
136 - Jack Shelton (Smithtown) dec. Paul Pereira (Brentwood), 3-2
141 - Mike Hyland (Kings Park) dec. Joe Sheppard (Smithtown), 6-2
148 - Tony Scanapico (Kings Park) dec. Rich Vanoor (Sachem), 3-2
157 - Bill Schlicting (Northport) dec. Fred Jayne (East Islip), 10-1
168 - Ray Farrell (Kings Park) pinned Charles Vion (Smithtown), 1:10
178 - Earl Flynn (Kings Park) dec. Lou Kitchner (Smithtown), 5-2
Hwt. - Bob Aerostatico (Kings Park) pinned Bob Morelli (Smithtown), 0:59
Most Outstanding Wrestler:
Most Pins Least Time:
Consolation Finals
106 - John MacNaught (Smithtown) pinned Rich Beard (Hauppauge), 1:53
112 - Buddy Fox (Smithtown) winner by forfeit over Ed Sattler (Sachem)
119 - Mike Granata (Kings Park) pinned John Nill (East Islip), 3:30
126 - John Cassese (Sachem) dec. Tom Manney (Smithtown), 2-0
131 - Dave Fortuna (Brentwood) pinned Tony Beccari (Northport), 1:50
136 - Frank Hansen (Islip) pinned Tom Johnson (Islip), 4:49
141 - John Avitable (Brentwood) dec. Dave Lisowy (Hauppauge), 5-0
148 - John Schumcker (Islip) dec. Gabriel Vignato (Bellport), 12-1
157 - Roger Keel (Kings Park) pinned Mike Hogan (Kings Park), 1:40
168 - Dennis Puleston Bell) dec. John Anselmo (Sachem), referee’s decision
178 - Tom Maltese (Northport) winner by forfeit Joe Corso (Hauppauge),
Hwt. –Henry Strufe (East Islip) pinned John Doxsee (Islip), 3:50

Bay Shore 26, Huntington 19
Tuesday-February 11, 1958 at Huntington; Non-League
103 - Steve Erber (Hu) pinned Chuck Geddes Jr., 3:51
109 - Rich Holohan (Hu) dec. Bill Worth, 6-3
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) pinned Roger Tetrault, 5:41
123 - Don Grenier (Hu) dec. Dan Grasso, 10-6
128 - Al Krus (BS) pinned Doug Helin, 3:29
133 - Jim Maguire (BS) dec. Pete Erber, 7-2
138 - Anthony Guccione (BS) dec. Cooke, 14-0
145 - Herbert Baker, Jr. (BS) pinned Herman, 3:27
154 - Richard Provenzano (Hu) dec. John Morrison, 9-2
165 - Phil Ferdinando (Hu) dec. Eddie Hubbard, 7-6
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) dec. Kurt Schwartz, 6-4
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) tied Gene Niedzieiski (Hu), 2-2.
 
Amityville 33, Bay Shore 8
Friday-February 7, 1958 at Bay Shore; Non-league
106 - James Willigan (Am) dec. Dennis McCulley, 12-3
112 - Bill Worth (BS) tied Santi Colloca (Am), 2-2
119 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) dec. Joe Lombardo (Am), 9-5
126 - Robert Donohue (Am) dec. Frank Toomey, 3-0
131 - John Schultis (Am) dec. Al Krus, 4-1
136 - Tom Coburn (Am) dec. Jim Maguire, 6-3
141 - Anthony Guccione (BS) pinned Pete Walker, 5:35
148 - Conrad Zimmerman (Am) dec. Jack Bahya, 9-3
157 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Kevin Carty, 7-6
168 - Brad Yates (Am) pinned Eddie Hubbard, 3:03
178 - Mike Spetko (Am) dec. Charles Schroeder, 8-1
Hwt - John Cutillo (Am) dec. Tom Ketcham, 2-0
 
Bay Shore 44, Kings Park 0
Tuesday-February 4, 1958 at Bay Shore; Non-League
103 - Dennis McCulley (BS) pinned Art Caieux, 3:50
109 - Bill Worth (BS) dec. Bob Seklowitz, 3-0
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) dec. Mike Granata, 8-4
123 - Weldersum (BS) pinned Overton, 1:30
128 - Al Krus (BS) dec. Dick Braille, 3:30
133 - Jim Maguire (BS) pinned Carey, 2:24
138 - Anthony Guccione (BS) dec. Mike Hyland, 9-7
145 - Herbert Baker, Jr. (BS) dec. Tony Scanapico, 9-6
154 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Kehoe, 4-2
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) dec. Ray Farrell, 7-1
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) dec. Earl Flynn, 6-0
Unl - Tom ` (BS) dec. Dick Aerostatico, 2-0
 
Bay Shore 33, Lindenhurst 8
Friday-January 30, 1958 at Lindenhurst; Non-League
103 - Charles Geddes Jr. (BS) pinned Burns, 3:45
109 - Alan McConnachie tied Warta, 11-11
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) dec. Bill Peterson, 7-2
123 - John Quigley (Lind) dec. Dan Grasso, 11-3
128 - Al Krus (BS) dec. Wrieth, 6-4
133 - Stu Meyerson (Lind) dec. Jim Maguire, 3-1
138 - Ronny Thomas (BS) dec. Sammis, 12-5
145 - Jim Griffin (BS) dec. Gehrlein, 4-2
154 - Joe Easley (BS) dec. Riggs, 6-2
165 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Smith, 9-5
175 - Richie Donaldson (BS) dec. Jost. 7-6
Unl - Pete Casale (BS) pinned Gregorio, 2:29
 
Bay Shore 29, Freeport 14
Wednesday-January 29, 1958 at Bay Shore; Non-League
103 - Tuttle (Fre) dec. Adolph Lipinski, 7-0
109 - Bill Worh (BS) dec. Taylor, 8-5
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) dec. Casquarelli, 6-40
123 - Basaelice (Fre) dec. Frank Toomey, 9-4
128 - F. White (Fre) dec. George Hubbard, 5-0
133 - Carman (Fre) dec. Jim Maguire, 4-1
138 - Anthony Guccione (BS) dec. Woelsel, 7-0
145 - Herbert Baker, Jr. (BS) dec. Homan, 3-0
154 - John Morrison (BS) won by default over Bill Tennell
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) pinned Layton, 2:49
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) pinned Guy Riccardi, 4:52
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) tied Dave Padgett, 2-2
 
Bay Shore 25. Port Jefferson 15
Friday-January 24, 1958 at Port Jefferson; Non-League
103 - Frank Hotcaveg (PJ) dec. Adolph Lipinski, 5-2
109 - Charlie Hotcaveg (PJ) dec. Bill Worth, 5-3
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) pinned Pastorelli, 4:18
123 - Duwane Russel(PJ) dec. Frank Toomey, 1-0
128 - George Hubbard (BS) pinned Alster, 4:15
133 - Schwender (PJ) dec. Ken Schroeder, 1-0
138 - Brian Petre (BS) dec. Turner, 4-3
145 - Herbert Baker, Jr. (BS) dec. Sehmus, 8-2
154 - Jackson (PJ) dec. Jim Griffin, 6-0
165 - Joe Easley (BS) dec. Kuefner, 2-0
175 - Richie Donaldson (BS) dec. Gildersleeve, 10-5
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) dec. Baxter Piercey, 5-1
 
Mepham 26, Bay Shore 8
Saturday-January 18, 1958 at Bay Shore; Non-League
103 - Cliff Furrer (Mep) pinned Adolph Lipinski, 1:31
109 - Mike Randall (Mep) pinned Bill Worth, 0:53
116 - Minsk (Mep) dec. Carmine Allegrezza, 5-0
123 - Ronnie Wieners (Mep) dec. Dan Grasso, 12-2
128 - Bickel (Mep) dec. Al Krus, 7-5
133 - Ryan (Mep) dec. Jim Maguire, 3-0
138 - Jacobs (Mep) pinned Ronny Thomas, 2:34
145 - Kienert (Mep) dec. Herbert Baker, Jr., 6-1
154 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Al Stevens, 5-2
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) pinned Joe Lynch, 5:25
175 - Ray Nickla (Mep) dec. Charles Schroeder,8-4
Unl - Dave Hayes (Mep) dec.Tom Ketcham, ?
  
Bay Shore 35, West Islip 13
Friday-January 17, 1958 at Bay Shore; Non-League
103 - John Ferry (WI) pinned Adolph Lipinsky, 3:54
109 - Bill Worth dec. John Factora, 11-5
116 - Joe Perrone (WI) pinned Carmine Allegrezza, 1:46
123 - Dan Grasso (BS) pinned Clausey, 3:42
128 - George Hubbard (BS) dec. Joe Costa, 9-4
133 - Ken Bossung (WI) dec. Ken Schroeder, 6-2
138 - Ronny Thomas (BS) dec. Seig, 11-8
145 - Jim Pigeon (BS) pinned F. Wallace, 1:29
154 - Joe Easley (BS)dec. J. Smith, 5-0
165 - Richie Donaldson (BS) dec. pinned Hardy, 3:27
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) pinned Al Bohlert, 4:40
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) dec.Passanante,6-2
 
Bay Shore 25, Farmingdale 15
Tuesday-January 14, 1958 at Farmingdale; Non-League
103 - Antonacci (Far) dec. Dennis McCulley, 5-3
109 - Bill Worth (BS) dec. Beneditto,7-2
116 - DellAquilla(Far) dec. Carmine Allegrezza, 5-4
123 - Dan Grasso (BS) dec. Fiano, 7-3
128 - Erickson (Far) dec. Al Krus, 9-7
133 - Jim Maguire (BS) dec. Farynick, 5-3
138 - Farynick (Far) dec. Ronny Thomas, 9-8
145 - Duffy(Far) dec. Herbert Baker, Jr., 3-2
154 - John Morrison (BS) dec. Burin, 5-2
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) pinned Peragine, 5:15
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) dec. Zollantano, 4-3
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) pinned Morano, 3:40
 
Bay Shore 44, Riverhead 6
Friday-January 10, 1958 at Riverhead; Non-League
103 - Alex Galvin (Riv) dec. Dennis McCulley, 2-0
109 - Bill Worth (BS) pinned Joe Czulada, 5:08
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) dec. Frank Sabotka, 9-3
123 - Dan Grasso (BS) pinned Mike Demchak, 4:55
128 - Al Krus (BS) pinned Bill Preeg, 5:15
133 - Ken Schroeder (BS) dec. John Cichanowicz, 2-0
138 - Jim Maguire (BS) dec. Jack Cappozzola, 3-0
145 - Herbert Baker, Jr. (BS) pinned Richard Winfree, 4:43
154 - John Morrison (BS) pinned Robert Brown, 5:58
165 - Louis (Skip) Schumejda (Riv) dec. Richie Donaldson, 8-5
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) pinned Ray Nelson, 0:38
Unl - Eddie Hubbard (BS) pinned Bill Moisa, 1:20
 
Bay Shore 26, Wantagh 14
Friday-December 20, 1957 at Bay Shore; Non-League
103 - Dennis McCulley (BS) dec. Durham, 8-4
109 - Keller (Wan) dec. Bob Anderson, 4-0
116 - Zimmer (Wan) dec. Carmine Allegrezza, 3-1
123 - Dan Grasso (BS) tied Cuneo (Wan), 6-6
128 - Prime (Wan) dec. George Hubbard, 5-0
133 - Jim Maguire (BS) pinned Contingnato, 3:08
138 - Anthony Guccione (BS) tied Herb Wolf (Wan), 6-6
145 - Herbert Baker, Jr. (BS) dec. Whidden, 5-1
154 - Delsignore (Wan) dec. John Morrison, 6-4
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) dec. Riordan, 7-0
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) pinned Smith, 3:30
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) dec. Corris, 4-0
 
Bay Shore 42, Islip 8
Friday-December 19, 1957 at Bay Shore; Non-League
103 - Joel Fanelli (BS) dec. R. Burch, 5-0
109 - Ronnie Hackett (Isp) pinned Bob Ackerson, 0:55
116 - DelGreco (Isp) dec. Jon Clark, 6-4
123 - Dan Grasso (BS) pinned Monteleone, 4:25
128 - George Hubbard (BS) pinned C. Behan, 1:02
133 - Ken Schroeder (BS) dec. Frank Hansen, 6-4
138 - Ronny Thomas (BS) pinned Tom Johnson, 3:25
145 - Jim Griffin (BS) dec. John Schmucker, 4-2
154 - Richie Samuelson (BS) dec. Butler, 4-2
165 - Joe Easley (BS) pinned Williams, 1:35
175 - Gene Metzger (BS) pinned F. Behan, 1:45
Unl - Richie Donaldson (BS) pinned John Doxsee, 3:00
 
Bay Shore 26, Valley Stream Central 21
Saturday-December 14, 1957 at Valley Stream Central; Non-League
103 - Anderson (VSC) pinned Adolph Lipinski, 3:55
109 - Justin Aquaviva (VSC) pinned Bill Worth, 1:00
116 - Don Pike (VSC) dec. Carmine Allegrezza, 10-7
123 - Dan Grasso (BS) dec. Coale, 10-8
128 - Bob Emmons (VSC) dec. Al Kruz, 13-2
133 - Jim Maguire (BS) dec. Schmidt, 5-0
138 - Anthony Guccione (BS) pinned Manetz, 4:15
145 - Herbert Baker Jr.  (BS) pinned Farish, 5:15
154 - John Morrison (BS) tied Argenton (VSC), 5-5
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) pinned Thorsen, 1:15
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) dec. Kahrs, ?-?
Unl - Les Cornell (VSC) dec. Tom Ketcham, 2-1

Bay Shore 49, Smithtown 5

Friday-December 13, 1957 at Smithtown; Non-League
103 - John McNaught (Sm) pinned Dennis McCulley, ?
109 - Bob Anderson (BS) dec. Bill Fox, 5-3
116 - Carmine Allegrezza (BS) won by forfeit
123 - Richard Wiedermsum (BS) pinned Mike Pascialla, ?
128 - George Hubbard (BS) pinned John Vanderlofske, ?
133 - Ken Schroeder (BS) pinned George Yachmowitz, ?
138 - Anthony Guccione (BS) dec. Jack Sheppard, 6-0
145 - Jim Pigeon (BS) pinned Frank Fishon, ?
154 - Gene Metzger (BS) pinned Chuck Vion, ?
165 - Eddie Hubbard (BS) pinned Tony Rombolo, ?
175 - Charles Schroeder (BS) pinned Charles Mortenson, ?
Unl - Tom Ketcham (BS) Bob Moselli, 1-0